Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing/Dip

Mar 3, 2011 by

The other day when we made wings, I went to grab some blue cheese dressing to serve with it. I couldn’t find one that wasn’t full of artificial ingredients, “low-fat,” or had possible gluten ingredients in it. So I bought some organic cave-aged blue cheese and made my own this past weekend.  I went to grab some yesterday to dip some raw zucchini with and it was even better after sitting for a few days. It was SO good, I had to share it with you guys. It was easy and is  honestly one of best blue cheese dressings I’ve ever had and it’s all natural. I use all organic dairy and of course, I recommend you do the same.

Edited to add:  Some people are concerned that blue cheese can be cross-contaminated with gluten due to the process of making it on the bread. However, from this site:

The Canadian Celiac Association recently released a study showing that blue cheese is in fact gluten-free. The study tested three blues where the mold is harvested off of gluten-containing media during production: Quebec’s St. Benoit and Alexis de Portneuf, and Roquefort. They also tested two cheeses where the mold was grown on gluten-free media. In all cases, they found that the resulting cheeses each contained less than one part per million of gluten. For comparison’s sake, the current definition of “gluten-free” being considered by the FDA is 20 parts per million. This puts these well below the limits set by the FDA (as well as its European equivalent). So blue cheese is a go for celiac sufferers!

My husband has never had an issue with it but of course, if this can be one of those things that fall into the “to each his own” category. It’s your health and you have to decide for yourself what you feel comfortable eating or testing.

Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing/Dip

What you need:

  • 4 oz. crumbled blue cheese
  • 1 c. mayo (make your own – so yummy!)
  • 1/3 c. sour cream
  • 1/4 c. cream cheese, softened
  • 2 tsp white cooking wine
  • 2 splashes Worcestershire sauce (make sure your brand is GF)
  • 1 tbsp scallions, chopped finely
  • 1/4 tsp. onion powder
  • 1/4 tsp garlic powder
  • 2 churns fresh ground black pepper

What you do:

  • Mix all ingredients together, that’s it!
  • This is pretty thick so if you want it thinner to be able to pour as a dressing on salads, add some buttermilk, milk, cream or your choice.
  • For best results, make 1-2 days prior to serving as the flavors really meld in the fridge after a few days.

Print Friendly

Related Posts

Share This

12 Comments

  1. yum! Thank you.

  2. Wendy

    Mmmm… can’t wait to try this. Do you have a recipe for Mayo too?

  3. Lauren

    Oh yum!!

    I love bleu cheese dressing so much…can’t wait to try this recipe!

  4. OK, I am so confused about blue cheese. I thought it was a no-no on gluten free diets, that it was somehow made with wheat, and yet on all the blue cheese at our co-op, it just lists regular cheese ingredients. Have you heard this? (I’m not gluten-free, but wheat-free b/c of allergies, if it makes a fig of difference, which I’m not sure it does.)

    • AndreAnna

      Hi, thanks for your comment! I just edited the post to include some recent information from the Celiac Sprue association who have updated with this:

      The Canadian Celiac Association recently released a study showing that blue cheese is in fact gluten-free. The study tested three blues where the mold is harvested off of gluten-containing media during production: Quebec’s St. Benoit and Alexis de Portneuf, and Roquefort. They also tested two cheeses where the mold was grown on gluten-free media. In all cases, they found that the resulting cheeses each contained less than one part per million of gluten. For comparison’s sake, the current definition of “gluten-free” being considered by the FDA is 20 parts per million. This puts these well below the limits set by the FDA (as well as its European equivalent). So blue cheese is a go for celiac sufferers! Enjoy!

  5. After being discouraged my mystery ingredients in store products, I decided the other day that I’d like to make my own blue cheese dressing. I think this recipe could be modified to be a dressing! Looks delish.

  6. This looks divine. I’ve been telling myself I need to find a non-industrial-oil homemade dipping recipe. Any idea of how long it would last in the fridge after mixing up?

    • AndreAnna

      Since it’s so high in fat, I would say it would last at least 3 weeks or more.

  7. Emily

    How much do you spend on groceries? You should do a post where you detail everything you buy in a week!

  8. I agree with Emily. I’d love to see an AndreAnna’s Stocked Pantry or Weekly Shopping List post! I haven’t had a stocked pantry since I threw all my poison/grains out. I miss feeling like I can whip up anything on a moment’s notice. :(

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Switch to our mobile site